Southern Caramel Cake

This delicious Southern Burnt Caramel Cake is a basic homemade butter cake topped with a cooked caramel frosting. The cake and frosting are made with simple ingredients easily found in most pantries—a true southern delight.

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

I was introduced to this recipe over 30 years ago. My mother-in-law was well known for her Burnt Caramel Cake. She always had some on hand, either fresh or stashed away in the freezer. With my crew around, this cake never makes it to the freezer. It always disappears within days. This is a tried and true recipe and is most definitely the best southern caramel cake around.

I made this recipe several times before I finally got the frosting right. The trick is to cook the frosting until it reaches the softball stage. Unfortunately, I didn’t use a candy thermometer the first few times I made this, and it just didn’t turn out quite right.

Why Make this Caramel Cake Recipe?

Birthday Celebrations: This cake is fabulous to serve for any occasion. My husband grew up eating this cake for holidays and even birthday celebrations. So he requested this cake for his last birthday, and it was a hit.

Holiday Desserts: This cake would be the talk at your holiday gatherings. This recipe is made for a sheet pan and will certainly feed a crowd.

Your Family: Everyone likes a good dessert. Make this for your family to enjoy between holidays and special occasions. It makes a lot and is perfect for the freezer.

What Ingredients are in this Recipe?

For the cake:

butter

sugar

flour

salt

baking powder

eggs

milk

vanilla

For the Burnt Caramel Frosting:

sugar

flour

milk

butter

vanilla

Tools Needed:

Some of the links on this page are affiliate links. Home at Cedar Springs Farm may earn a small commission for purchases made after clicking links on this page. Learn More.

Mixer — I used a stand mixer.

Flour sifter— Not 100% needed, but does help with getting all of the lumps out.

Sheet Cake Pan— I used my mother in laws cake pans. It’s a 12″ x 18″ pan.

Parchment paper (optional)– I would grease and flour a pan. Using parchment paper would keep the cake from sticking, but it makes it harder to cut into slices and get out of the pan.

Iron Skillet— I recommend an iron skillet, but a large heavy bottom pan would work.

Saucepot— Choose a larger than needed pan. This keeps things from boiling over.

Whisk— This is needed to whisk the caramel sauce to perfection.

Wooden Spoon

Spatula for spreading— I used an offset spatula for spreading.

Candy Thermometer— This is needed to get the caramel to the correct temperature.

How to Make this Caramel Cake Recipe

For the cake:

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

Grease and flour a 12″ x 18″ sheet pan.

In a stand mixer, Cream the butter, then add sugar- Creaming until light and fluffy.

Sift flour with baking powder and salt.

To the creamed butter and sugar mixture, alternate adding flour mixture, eggs (1 at a time), and milk, beating after each addition.

Add vanilla. Mix well.

Pour into a well-greased sheet pan 12″ x 18″. Bake at 350 degrees for 25-30 minutes. Cool completely before frosting.

For the caramel frosting:

Combine the 3 3/4 cup sugar, flour, and milk in a medium saucepot. Bring to a boil over medium heat. As this is coming to a boil, make the browned sugar. I use a medium iron skillet to brown the sugar.

Browned Sugar: To the iron skillet, add 3/4 cup sugar. Over medium heat and with a wooden spoon, melt the sugar. After 5 minutes, you will notice the sugar begins to clump and melt. Stir and break up any clumps with the back of your spoon. The sugar will start to melt and change color. It will turn light brown then caramel brown. Stir until all sugar has melted and the color is medium brown. Move off the heat when done.

Place a candy thermometer into the saucepan with the milk mixture. Slowly add the browned sugar to the boiling milk mixture -stirring fast—Cook to a softball stage on the thermometer. If you don’t have a candy thermometer, drop a small amount into a cup of cold water. It should form a soft ball. Remove from heat. Add butter and vanilla. Cool for about 15 minutes-whisking every 5 minutes. After 15 minutes, begin whisking continuously for 5 minutes, checking for thickness. You are looking for thick and pourable frosting. Pour over the cooled cake and spread evenly. Place the frosted cake into the refrigerator to chill to help the caramel set up on the cake.

Add melted browned sugar to milk mixture — Add Browned sugar

Add a candy thermometer and cook to a softball stage — Add candy thermometer
and cook to softball stage

Pour caramel frosting over cooled cake — Pour caramel over
cooled cake

Spread frosting over cake — Spread frosting
over cake

Cut into squares and serve.

Notes: **I test my frosting for thickness by letting it run off a spoon. If it slides off and none sticks to the spoon, then it’s not ready. But if you let it run off of the spoon and some of it clings to the spoon, it’s ready for the cake.

Expert Tips

*Make the cake first and cool completely before starting on the frosting.

*A wooden spoon has always worked best for me when melting sugar.

*Watch the sugar closely and stir continuously while browning. It will burn if not careful.

*You will need a medium to a large saucepot. Once the browned sugar is added to the boiling liquid, it will foam a bit until it settles back down. You don’t want this boiling over onto your stovetop.

*Slowly pour the browned sugar into the boiling milk mixture.

*This frosting is not an easy frosting to make. But with some patience, a candy thermometer, and a little time, you will master this frosting with no problem at all.

*Make sure your frosting is thick enough to spread but pourable. Cooling the frosting and beating it will thicken it up.

**I test my frosting for thickness by letting it run off a spoon. If it slides off and none sticks to the spoon, then it’s not ready. But if you let it run off of the spoon and some of it clings to the spoon, it’s ready for the cake.

*Place the cake into the refrigerator to allow the frosting to set up faster. *Store the cake in the refrigerator.

Recipe FAQ’s

Burnt sugar is actually not burned at all. Burned sugar is the caramelization of sugar. It is basically melting sugar until it turns a dark brown. You need to stir the sugar while melting to ensure you do not burn it. This method requires your full attention to get this process right the first time.

If this process is done correctly, then no. Burnt sugar is used in desserts to provide a dark, rich sweetness. The burnt sugar provides flavor and color to the caramel topping in this particular recipe.

I like to slice all leftovers into small squares. I then place them into an airtight container and put them in the refrigerator.

To Freeze: I slice the leftover cake into small squares. Next, I place the cake into a freezer-safe container, separate each layer with parchment paper, and put it in the freezer. The cake will last for several months in the freezer.